At the Crossville City Council meeting on September 9, 2025, a pivotal discussion centered on a motion to establish a city-run EMS transport service under the Crossville Fire Department’s oversight, with a phased implementation starting around July 1, 2026.

Supporters argued that a fire-based EMS would leverage strategically located fire stations for faster response times, enhance job satisfaction by cross-training firefighters to reduce burnout, and allow the city to control its EMS operations, potentially benefiting the broader county. They acknowledged a possible tax increase but emphasized a disciplined approach to minimize costs.

Opponents, including Mayor RJ Crawford and Council member James Mayberry, highlighted the county’s existing top-ranked EMS system, which has earned state awards and ranks in Tennessee’s top quartile. They expressed concern over the proposed 30-cent property tax increase per $100 of assessed value, equating to a 50% tax hike given the current 60-cent rate, with best-case scenarios projecting a 75% increase and worst-case scenarios a doubling of taxes.

Critics argued this would unfairly burden fixed-income residents and double-tax city property owners for services already provided by the county, suggesting alternatives like grant funding and a slower, more responsible approach.

Public commenter Ronald Bodari echoed these concerns, citing Mount Juliet’s significant tax increase for a similar service and urging fiscal stewardship.

Despite opposition, the motion passed 3-2 via roll call, with Council members Mike Turner, Mark Fox, and Art Gernt voting in favor, and Mayor Crawford and Council member James Mayberry member opposed.